Medaka eggs with visible eyes that do not hatch: why, and what to do

Eggs that still show a black dot in the centre after three weeks of waiting, a single fry out, an incubation at room temperature with a little methylene blue: the situation repeats every autumn. The answer comes down to one rule and three checks: a medaka egg hatches when it has accumulated about 250 degree-days, and if it does not open well beyond that, it is almost always a matter of temperature, light or oxygen. Here is how to read the situation, save what can be saved, and not go through the wait again.

What the black dot means, and what it does not mean

The black dot in the centre of the egg is the embryo’s eyes. They appear early: three to four days after spawning when the water is warm, around the eighth to twelfth day when it is cool. An egg that shows its eyes is therefore fertilised and alive at the moment you see them. But it is not a sign of imminent hatching: the embryo still has half of its development ahead of it. Two eyes tell you nothing about the hatching date; temperature alone fixes it.

A fertilised egg is transparent, amber, firm under light pressure. An unfertilised egg turns white within a few days and squashes under the finger. Between the two, an egg that showed its eyes and then began to whiten, to go soft or milky, contains an embryo that died in its shell, which Japanese breeders describe as the fourth cause of failure, after low temperature, unfertilised eggs and mould.

The 250 degree-day rule, applied to “room temperature”

Multiply the water temperature by the number of days. Hatching comes at around 250, with a margin: Japanese breeders observe hatching from 230 and sometimes only beyond 260, depending on the strain, the water quality and the oxygen. This gives:

Water temperature Expected hatching
25 °C 10 days
22 °C 11 to 12 days
20 °C 13 days
18 °C 14 to 15 days
15 °C about 25 days according to an experiment cited in Japan, with heavy mortality

“Room temperature” in a house in autumn means water at 18 or 20 °C, sometimes 16 °C on a windowsill at night. At 18 °C, three weeks represent nearly 380 degree-days: the eggs should have hatched a week ago. At 16 °C, you reach 336, also beyond. The only case where three weeks stays within the norm is water at 12 or 13 °C, and at that temperature development slows so much that the embryo exhausts itself before emerging. Japanese sources put the critical threshold at around 15 °C: below it, development becomes very slow, and below 10 °C it stops; a fertilised egg that stays a long time in this zone dies without hatching. Even above that, cold is costly: at 25 °C, a well-managed batch hatches at over 90%; below 20 °C, the rate can fall towards 50%.

The conclusion for the case described: with eyes visible and three weeks at room temperature, this is no longer a late hatch but eggs that will probably not hatch any more. The one that came out proves the clutch was fertilised; the others lacked warmth, and probably light or oxygen.

The three other factors that temperature hides

Light

A medaka egg needs a day-night rhythm. Tokyo Aqua Garden makes this a condition of hatching: the eggs need to be exposed to daylight, and failing that, an aquarium or grow LED lamp. A Japanese breeder observes that a batch kept in a dark room hatches distinctly less well than one placed near a window, provided you avoid full summer sun, which overheats a small container. In October, a window is the ideal place.

Oxygen

The egg breathes. In still water, oxygen runs short, and the embryo, cramped in its shell in the last days, is the first to suffer. Japanese breeders recommend a wide, shallow container, a flat box or a cup, which offers a large exchange surface for little water; a daily water change, which renews the oxygen and removes what dead eggs release; and, if you want to do better, a very gentle movement of water. A deep, narrow jar that is never renewed is the worst of incubators.

Methylene blue left too long

Methylene blue is used during the first half of incubation, against mould, at the dose of water barely tinted. As soon as the eyes appear, the eggs go into water with no product, as explained in spawning, eggs and incubation. No Japanese source claims that the blue prevents hatching. On the other hand, all say that a fry born in blue water tolerates it badly, especially if the dose has concentrated through evaporation and repeated top-ups. Three weeks in the blue is too long for the newborn, and it is also a sign that the water has not been renewed.

Mould, a consequence of the delay

The longer incubation drags on, the more time fungi have to settle on dead eggs and spread to their neighbours by contact. A slow incubation is doubly risky: through the cold, and through the mould that the cold lets prosper.

What to do now

  1. Measure the temperature of the water in the container, in the morning, with a thermometer, and do the calculation. Beyond 300 accumulated degree-days, waiting makes no more sense.
  2. Sort the eggs. Keep those that are still clear, firm, with sharp eyes and, under a magnifier, an embryo that moves or a heart that beats. Discard those that are white, milky, soft, or whose contents have taken on a uniform grey tint.
  3. Move the survivors to a flat container, with clean water and no blue, at 24 or 26 °C: a box placed on an aquarium heating mat, or floating in a heated aquarium, or simply in the warmest room of the house, near a window. Equalise the temperature over an hour, not all at once.
  4. Renew the water every day, at the same temperature, and give light by day, darkness at night.
  5. Wait one week, no more. What is going to hatch hatches within this time, most often in the morning, over two or three days. After that, discard the rest.

The fry that emerge move on to raising the fry: they live two to three days on their yolk sac, and eat from the third day. For what comes next indoors, volumes, water and temperature, see raising fry indoors.

For the next clutch

  • Incubate at 24 or 26 °C from the first day, in a flat, clear container, placed in the light. In autumn, this means a heater or a warm room, not “room temperature”.
  • Note the collection date and the temperature: the hatching day can be predicted.
  • Methylene blue barely tinting the water, water changed every day, white eggs removed every day, blue stopped as soon as the eyes are visible.
  • Avoid sudden variations: Japanese breeders judge that a sudden temperature swing harms an egg more than water that is a little cool but stable.
  • Eggs laid in October by pond-kept parents often come from end-of-season tired females: the batches are smaller and more fragile. Incubate what you can heat, and leave the rest.

Frequently asked questions

The eyes have been visible for ten days, and the water is at 20 °C. Should I worry?

Not yet. At 20 °C, the eyes appear around the eighth day and hatching around the thirteenth. Count the degree-days from spawning, not from the eyes.

Can you help a fry out of its egg?

No. A fry that cannot pierce its shell lacks oxygen or strength; you help it by changing the water, gently raising the temperature and giving light, never by touching the egg.

Only one fry came out of the whole clutch: is it viable?

Yes, as long as it swims and eats from the third day. Raise it alone in a small volume, in the warm, with fry powder or green water.

Can methylene blue kill the eggs?

At the dose of barely tinted water, no. Concentrated by evaporation, or kept until hatching, it harms the fry more than the egg. It does not on its own explain a clutch that does not hatch.

Sources

  • Tokyo Aqua Garden, “メダカの卵を見つけた・取ったら” (you have found or collected medaka eggs), t-aquagarden.com: exposing the eggs to daylight or an LED, flat container for oxygen, methylene blue and tap water against mould.
  • メダカの飼い方.com, “メダカの卵に目が見えてから孵化まで!孵化しないのはなぜ!?” (from visible eyes to hatching: why it does not hatch), 2021, updated 1 July 2026, medaka.papa77.com: eyes around day 3 or 4, 25 days at 15 °C, hatching rate of 90% at 25 °C against 50% below 20 °C, role of light, dark room.
  • 日淡といっしょ, “メダカの卵が孵化しない原因と日数の目安” (why eggs do not hatch, timescales), nittanwith.com: margin of 230 to 260 degree-days, development much slowed below 15 °C and stopped below 10 °C, oxygen and still water, sudden variations, methylene blue reduced as hatching approaches.
  • 和香 (nagoyaka), “メダカの卵が孵化しない原因6選と対処法” (six causes and remedies), nagoyakashop.jp: embryo dead in the shell, recognition by touch and colour, long incubation and mould.
  • Medakaya En, “メダカの卵が孵化しない原因” (why eggs do not hatch), medakayaen-ec.com: delay in cool water is the most frequent cause, especially in early spring.
  • medaka.fr, spawning, eggs and incubation: 250 degree-day rule, methylene blue dose, blue stopped when the eyes are visible.