Videos promise “amazing” results when you put oak leaves in a medaka tank. What really happens is more modest and better understood: Japanese breeders have put dead leaves in their tubs for a long time, mostly persimmon leaves for the winter, and they have documented the benefits, the limits and the failures. This page says what tannins do to the water, what the medaka gets from them, what it risks, and how to prepare and dose oak leaves collected in Europe.
What the leaves do to the water
A dead leaf soaking in water releases tannins and humic acids. The water takes on a tea colour, what aquarists call blackwater, and becomes very slightly acidic. Tokyo Aqua Garden describes the mechanism and immediately sets its measure: “the pH does not drop abruptly, and the medaka adapts to a wide range of water qualities”. A Japanese breeder explains why: tap water contains carbonates, the so-called KH, which buffer acids, and the acids from leaves are “extremely weak acids”. A French shop specialising in shrimp, which has measured its tanks for ten years, puts the effect of pedunculate oak, Quercus robur, at a drop of 0.1 to 0.3 pH units at most, over two to four weeks, and at less than 0.1 unit in water of KH 5 to 8, which is in the range of many tap waters. A catappa leaf, richer, gives 0.2 to 0.8 units. In very soft water, the effect is stronger.
Two consequences that the videos do not show. Water that is too acidic slows the nitrifying bacteria that convert ammonia, which Tokyo Aqua Garden points out as the downside of blackwater. And amber water filters light: plants grow less, and above all, “you cannot have blackwater and green water at the same time”. For a medaka keeper, who relies on green water to feed the fry, that is the deciding point.
What the medaka gets from it, and what it does not
The medaka is not a blackwater fish. It comes from the rice fields and ditches of Japan, whose water is neutral to slightly alkaline. A Japanese medaka shop measures its green-water tubs at a pH of 10 and natural habitats between 7.5 and 8; it puts the comfort zone between 6.5 and 8, with a preference for 7 to 8. The breeder Hime-medaka says it bluntly: “the medaka is a Japanese fish, and the rivers and ponds of Japan are not acidic”; leaves rich in tannins come from the world of bettas, apistos and discus. Acidifying the water is therefore not a goal, and an oak leaf will not change the colour of a medaka: the effect on colour is claimed for South American fish and shrimp, never for it.
The antibacterial effect is repeated everywhere, and always in the conditional. Tokyo Aqua Garden writes that humic acids “have an antibacterial action, from which a preventive effect can be expected” and that bacteria such as Aeromonas “are said to be held back to a certain extent”; Hime-medaka speaks of limiting moulds and the flora of the water. None of these sources gives a measurement. A professional breeder in Yokohama draws the opposite conclusion: he does not see how to verify that the tannins from a leaf in a small tub have any effect at all, “a bare tub gets through the winter very well”, and what counts is volume, depth, healthy water and well-fed fish before winter. Both positions are honest: the leaf does no harm in small amounts, and it cannot be proved to protect.
What is better established comes down to two points. Shelter: in the wild, medaka overwinter buried under the leaf litter at the bottom of watercourses, and GEX advises “leaves from deciduous trees, free of pesticides, moss or wood, so that the fish can hide and settle”. A medaka at rest is very sensitive to what passes above it, and a layer of leaves reassures it. Then microfauna: a decomposing leaf feeds infusoria, daphnia and micro-organisms that the fry eat; one Japanese breeder found that his daphnia multiplied in a tub furnished with persimmon leaves, another that fry grew without feeding in a biotope with leaves, while admitting himself that the rest of the pond could explain it. The adult medaka, however, does not eat the leaf. Thermal insulation, often claimed, is judged marginal or nil by those who have looked for it.
The risks, documented by those who went about it badly
- Rot. A leaf is organic matter, like leftover food. In too large a quantity, or in a spring thaw, it rots, clouds the water and degrades it. A breeder who had put twenty to thirty persimmon leaves in a tub found in spring “cloudy water and mosquito larvae”.
- Thin leaves and fresh leaves. A thin leaf rots quickly and goes mouldy; a leaf that is still green “rots and gives off a smell”: use only fallen, dry leaves, thick ones by preference.
- Pesticides. Japanese persimmons are treated, and so are trees in parks and by roadsides here. All the sources demand washing, and collecting away from roads and orchards.
- Passengers. Leaves carry snail eggs and sometimes leaf fungi.
- Salt. Some people preserve persimmon leaves in brine: in the tank, the salt diffuses, kills the bacteria and the leaf goes mouldy. Never salted leaves.
- Sacrificed green water. In a fry tub that you want green, no leaves.
Which leaf in Europe
Oak is the right choice: a thick leaf that breaks down slowly, with moderate tannins. Beech also works, even more neutral. Maple, sweet chestnut and dogwood are cited in Japan. Walnut, whose leaves contain juglone, laurel, and conifers are to be excluded. The persimmon leaf, if you have the tree, is the one Japanese breeders use. The commercial catappa leaf does the same thing in a more concentrated form: start with a single one and aim for the colour of a light tea. Autumn leaves that have fallen by themselves are the only ones to take.
Preparing and dosing
- Collect fallen, dry, whole leaves, away from roads, orchards and treated parks.
- Wash in clean water, then dry thoroughly, two to three days, until they are brittle. A badly dried leaf gets covered with a white film within a few days. Dry, they keep for years.
- Soak for a day or two in a bucket of cold water, changing the water once: this draws out the strongest tannins and the leaves sink. Opinions differ on boiling water: thirty seconds to two minutes at most if you insist, more leaches the tannins and serves no purpose.
- Dose by volume, never by the number of fish. Hime-medaka gives the most precise rule: two or three leaves of 10 to 20 cm, about ten grams, for 60 L. For a 30 L tub, one or two oak leaves. Start low, watch the colour of the water, and only then add more.
- Remove when only the veins remain, and in any case in spring, around April, before rising temperatures speed up decomposition. In Japan, the leaves go in in November and come out at the end of March: four months.
In an outdoor tub that is overwintering, the oak leaf therefore has its place, as shelter. In an indoor medaka aquarium, it brings nothing that the fish needs, and it costs the plants light. In a fry tub, it feeds the microfauna but prevents green water: you choose.
The figures to remember
| Medaka comfort zone | pH 6.5 to 8, preference for 7 to 8 |
|---|---|
| Effect of an oak leaf on pH | 0.1 to 0.3 unit at most in soft water, less than 0.1 in ordinary tap water |
| Dose | 2 to 3 leaves or 10 g for 60 L; 1 to 2 leaves for 30 L |
| Drying | 2 to 3 days, leaf brittle |
| Soaking | 1 to 2 days in cold water, water changed once |
| Time in the tank | November to the end of March; remove when only the veins remain |
| Too many | 20 to 30 leaves in a tub: cloudy water and mosquitoes in spring |
| Never | fresh, thin, salted or treated leaves; walnut, laurel, conifers |
Frequently asked questions
Do oak leaves cure sick medaka?
No. The antibacterial effect of tannins is repeated in the conditional and has never been measured in the medaka. A sick fish is treated with water, the salt bath and isolation, not with a leaf.
Can I put some in an indoor aquarium?
One or two, clean and dry, will do no harm. They will not bring anything visible either, and the plants will lose light.
The water has turned brown. Is that serious?
A light tea colour is normal. Dark brown or cloudy water means too many leaves or leaves that are rotting: take some out and change a third of the water.
What about the persimmon leaf?
It is the leaf Japanese breeders use for winter, thick and slow to break down. If you have an untreated persimmon, it is as good as oak. Otherwise, oak does the job very well.
Sources
- Tokyo Aqua Garden, “メダカにブラックウォーターっていいの?” (is blackwater good for medaka?), 2023, updated 2026, t-aquagarden.com; “マジックリーフとは” (the catappa leaf), t-aquagarden.com; “ブラックウォーターとは” (blackwater), t-aquagarden.com: tannins and humic acids, expected antibacterial effect, slowed nitrification, incompatibility with green water, dosing by colour.
- Hime-medaka, “メダカ飼育での柿の葉(落ち葉)の使い方と注意点” (persimmon leaves: use and precautions), hime-medaka.com: 2 to 3 leaves or 10 g for 60 L, pesticides, the medaka is not an acidic-water fish.
- GEX, “屋外飼育、冬に備えて” (outdoor keeping, preparing for winter), 2016, gex-fp.co.jp: leaves of deciduous trees free of pesticides as overwintering shelter.
- さかなと環境ブログ, “冬のメダカに「柿の葉」を使う理由” (why use persimmon leaves for winter medaka), 2025, sakana-kankyo.com: overwintering under leaf litter in the wild, soaking, November to March, the excess of 20 to 30 leaves.
- メダクワ!, “メダカの越冬に柿の葉は必要?” (are persimmon leaves necessary for overwintering medaka?), 2022, medakakuwagata.com: daphnia, fresh leaves that rot, removal in April, no hot water.
- Medakaya En, breeder in Yokohama, “柿の葉などの落ち葉を入れる必要ない!” (no need for dead leaves): unverifiable effect, priority to volume and the condition of the fish; きんぎょりうむ, “メダカの冬眠に落ち葉がもたらすメリット、デメリット” (the pros and cons of dead leaves for medaka hibernation), 2021: shelter, marginal insulation, snails, rot.
- 雑貨屋サン, “メダカに適したpHは?” (what pH suits the medaka?), zakkaya-sun.shop: pH 6.5 to 8, green water at 10, habitats at 7.5 to 8, avoid sudden variations.
- Shrimp-délice, “Feuilles naturelles pour crevettes d’aquarium” (natural leaves for aquarium shrimp), 2025, blog.shrimp-delice.fr: pedunculate oak 0.1 to 0.3 unit, role of KH, drying 48 to 72 h, walnut and laurel, dosing by volume (in-house measurements, shrimp context).
- Annie Roi, “Utiliser des feuilles d’arbre dans l’aquarium” (using tree leaves in the aquarium), 2020, annieroi.com: usable species, conifers excluded, infusoria and shelter for fry, removal at the veins.