Which Animals to Keep with Medaka? Snails, Shrimps and Companions

The best companions for a medaka are invertebrates: snails such as ramshorn snails or mystery snails, and shrimps such as Neocaridina or the Amano. Fish are rarely suitable, because almost all of them eat eggs and fry, and many do not overwinter outdoors in much of Europe. Several classic companions in Japanese guides, starting with the dojō loach, are banned in the European Union: we flag them separately.

Three questions before adding an animal

The medaka measures 3 to 4 cm and is peaceful, but its eggs and fry are prey for almost everything that lives in water, its own parents included. Three questions decide.

  • Does it eat medaka, eggs or fry?
  • Does it tolerate the same water and the same winter? An outdoor tub goes from 30 °C in summer to a frozen surface in winter.
  • Is it legal? Regulation (EU) No 1143/2014 forbids keeping, selling, transporting or breeding the species on the Union list. France has its own lists, and protects native species that may not be taken from the wild.

One rule applies to all: you never release anything into the wild, neither the medaka nor its companions. See releasing a medaka into the wild.

Snails

These are the simplest companions: the common freshwater snails do not attack a living medaka. Their only fault is to swarm when you overfeed.

Ramshorn snails, bladder snails and pond snails

They often arrive on their own, clinging to plants. Ramshorn snails, including the red varieties sold commercially, and bladder snails graze the film of algae and overwinter outdoors. The commonest bladder snail, Physella acuta, is said to be of North American origin. Pond snails (limnaeids), which are larger, also eat tender plants: keep them in check in a planted tub. Bladder snails make a dead fry disappear in a night, which hides losses: see fry indoors and algae.

River snails

River snails (Viviparus viviparus, Viviparus contectus) are native operculate snails, with a shell reaching about 4 cm. They are live-bearing: the female gives birth to fully formed young, in modest numbers. They graze and also filter the water (Höckelmann and Pusch, 2000), and spend the winter on the bottom. They are the European equivalent of the tanishi (タニシ) of Japanese tubs. You buy them, you do not collect them from a pond: leeches, parasites and dragonfly larvae come with them.

Nerites and trumpet snails: indoors only

Nerites (Neritina) clean glass well and do not breed in fresh water, but according to French fact sheets they need hard water and at least 20 °C. The trumpet snail (Melanoides tuberculata) is tropical, lives buried in sand and multiplies on its own, without a male. Heated aquarium only.

Apple snails: no

The genus Pomacea is a Union quarantine organism: Decision 2012/697/EU forbade its introduction and spread, and it appears in Annex II of Implementing Regulation (EU) 2019/2072, supplemented by Implementing Regulation (EU) 2024/2013. The Colombian ramshorn, Marisa cornuarietis, has been on the Union list since 7 August 2025. We do not recommend them.

Shrimps

Neocaridina davidi (red cherry and its varieties)

Small, it eats leftovers and algae and breeds in fresh water. Medaka eat some of the young shrimps (Tokyo Aqua Garden): Java moss gives them refuge. It does not hunt a healthy fry, but does eat a weakened fry lying on the bottom. Tokyo Aqua Garden says they can overwinter outdoors, but it is talking about the shrimp native to Japan; the red cherries sold in Europe are bred strains. We are testing them outdoors at Lesneven this winter, 2026-2027, and will give the result here in spring; in the meantime, bring them indoors or keep them in a deep tub that does not freeze to the bottom.

Caridina multidentata (Amano, Yamato)

It measures 3 to 5 cm and does not breed in fresh water: its larvae need salt water. It is the best against filamentous algae. Being larger, it can eat eggs and fry, warns Tokyo Aqua Garden: no Amano in a spawning tub or a fry tub. It tolerates cold and can overwinter outdoors if the water does not freeze. In Brittany, a deep tub suits it; in colder continental and northern climates, bring it indoors (see overwintering).

Shrimps to avoid

Tokyo Aqua Garden rules out carnivorous shrimps (Tenaga-ebi, over 10 cm, and Suji-ebi) and the red bee, too sensitive to the water. The native shrimp of southern France, Atyaephyra desmarestii, is not protected but is rarely sold: do not collect it. Freshwater gammarids arrive on their own with plants and eat debris.

How many snails and shrimps?

No source consulted gives a density per litre: there is no ratio, writes a Japanese blog, it is the total load of the tub that counts. Tokyo Aqua Garden advises starting with a few individuals. A shrimp eats and fouls: count it in the load, alongside the rule of one litre per medaka. Our benchmark at Lesneven, for a 40 litre tub: 5 to 10 shrimps and 5 snails.

Fish

Those that can go in

The white cloud mountain minnow (Tanichthys albonubes, the Akahire of the Japanese) is the size of a medaka and lives between 2 and 22 °C according to Fishipedia. The adults tolerate each other, but this carnivore will take the eggs, and a tub in the sun exceeds its 22 °C in summer. A companion for a cool aquarium or a shaded tub, not for a breeding tub.

The Notropis goes only in a large pond: see medaka and Notropis chrosomus.

In a heated aquarium, Tokyo Aqua Garden cites Corydoras, small rasboras and tetras, at about 26 °C. Otocinclus, for its part, needs at least 21 °C. We recommend them only in an aquarium that is already heated for another reason, Daruma or winter spawning: see keeping medaka in an aquarium.

Those that do not

  • Goldfish and koi: no, they chase and swallow medaka. See medaka and goldfish.
  • Sticklebacks: native, voracious, and the male defends his nest in spring. They eat eggs and fry.
  • Guppies, platies, mollies: tropical, they eat fry and multiply fast.
  • Betta: tropical, and the male nips long fins, those of a Longfin first.
  • Bitterling, weatherfish (pond loach), spined loach: native, and in France protected by the order of 8 December 1988, which forbids destroying or removing their eggs. Do not collect them.
  • Mosquitofish, topmouth gudgeon, pumpkinseed: banned, see below.

Amphibians and small fauna

Frogs and newts arrive on their own. All amphibians in France are protected by the order of 8 January 2021, spawn included: you do not introduce them, you do not capture them. See medaka and frogs. Dragonfly larvae, diving beetle larvae and backswimmers are predators, not companions: see predators of medaka, which also covers hydra.

Daphnia, copepods and water hoglice are the useful fauna of the tub. Daphnia eat phytoplankton and serve as live food, water hoglice recycle debris. In a fry tub, be wary of copepods. Daphnia from a pond can bring in hydra.

Freshwater mussels and crayfish: no

Mussels filter micro-organisms that are scarce in a small volume. Tokyo Aqua Garden judges survival beyond a year “very difficult”; a dead mussel stays closed and rots unseen. The freshwater pearl mussel and the thick-shelled river mussel (Unio crassus) are protected in France by the order of 23 April 2007. The golden mussel (Limnoperna fortunei) and the quagga mussel are banned. The Asian clam (Corbicula) is invasive in French rivers.

Crayfish eat medaka; even Tokyo Aqua Garden rules them out. American crayfish are banned: red swamp crayfish (Procambarus clarkii), marbled crayfish (Procambarus virginalis), spiny-cheek crayfish (Faxonius limosus), signal crayfish (Pacifastacus leniusculus), and since 2025 Faxonius immunis and the yabby Cherax destructor. Native crayfish, such as the white-clawed crayfish, are protected.

What Japanese sites recommend that is banned in the EU or in France

Japanese guides write for the fauna of Japan. Several of their companions are invasive here.

Recommended in Japan What it is In the EU and France
Dojō (ドジョウ), golden dojō (ヒドジョウ) Misgurnus anguillicaudatus Banned: Union list since 7 August 2025, with M. bipartitus (Implementing Regulation (EU) 2025/1422). Our native loaches are protected in France. No equivalent.
Shima-dojō (シマドジョウ) Japanese loach of the genus Cobitis Not on the market; its equivalent, the spined loach, is protected in France.
Tanishi (タニシ), large tanishi Cipangopaludina Banned: C. chinensis on the Union list since 7 August 2025. Equivalent: the river snail.
Hime-tanishi (ヒメタニシ) Sinotaia quadrata histrica Not on the list, not on the market. Equivalent: the river snail.
Yamato numa-ebi (ヤマトヌマエビ) Caridina multidentata Allowed, sold under the name Amano.
Minami numa-ebi (ミナミヌマエビ) Neocaridina denticulata Allowed equivalent: Neocaridina davidi, the red cherry.
Ishimaki-gai (石巻貝) Japanese nerite Equivalent: the nerite, in an aquarium.
Ramshorn (ラムズホーン) coloured ramshorn snails Allowed.
Akahire (アカヒレ) Tanichthys albonubes Allowed.
Motsugo (モツゴ), native fish of Japanese biotopes Pseudorasbora parva Banned: Union list since 2016, Annex II-1 of the French order of 14 February 2018.
Bitterlings (タナゴ) and spawning mussels Rhodeus, unionids The European bitterling is protected. No mussels.

Also banned: mosquitofish (Gambusia affinis, G. holbrooki), Union list since 2022, Annex II-4 of the French order since 2023, and the pumpkinseed (Lepomis gibbosus), listed since 2019, Annex II-3. Against mosquitoes, the medaka is enough: see medaka and mosquitoes.

The summary table

Companion Outdoors in winter Indoors Risk to eggs and fry Verdict
Ramshorn snail, bladder snail yes yes low; eat the dead yes
Pond snail yes yes low; eats plants in small numbers
River snail yes yes low yes, bought
Nerite no yes, ≥ 20 °C low aquarium
Apple snail no regulated eats plants no
Neocaridina on trial at Lesneven this winter yes weakened fry yes
Amano if the water does not freeze yes eggs and fry yes, not in the fry tub
White cloud mountain minnow yes, unheated eggs and fry adults only
Corydoras, Otocinclus no heated low heated aquarium only
Goldfish, stickleback, guppy not applicable not applicable high no
Dojō, mosquitofish, topmouth gudgeon, pumpkinseed not applicable not applicable not applicable banned
Mussels, crayfish not applicable not applicable high no

Frequently asked questions

Dojō loaches already live with my medaka. What should I do?

Above all, do not release them. Article 31 of Regulation (EU) No 1143/2014 allows a private individual who kept a pet animal before its listing to keep it until its natural death, provided it can neither breed nor escape. No more buying, selling or giving away.

Do shrimps eat medaka eggs?

The Amano does, according to Tokyo Aqua Garden. Neocaridina mainly eat dead eggs and weak fry. But adult medaka also eat their own eggs: a missing egg incriminates no one. The only sure protection remains to collect the eggs and raise the fry separately.

My tub is overrun with snails. Should I remove them?

Remove some by hand, then cut back the food. It is the leftovers that make them swarm.

Sources

  • Tokyo Aqua Garden, メダカと一緒に飼える魚や生き物は何がいる? (the animals to keep with medaka), 2021, updated in 2026: criteria, dojō, tropicals, shrimps, snails, animals to avoid, t-aquagarden.com.
  • Tokyo Aqua Garden, メダカとエビの関係性 (medaka and shrimps), 2022, updated in 2026: Yamato, Minami, red cherry, shrimps to avoid, t-aquagarden.com.
  • Tokyo Aqua Garden, アクアリウムの二枚貝とは (bivalves in the aquarium), 2026, t-aquagarden.com.
  • 水草水槽.com, ミナミヌマエビはメダカを襲う? (does the Minami attack medaka?), 2021, updated in 2022: no ratio, eggs and weak fry eaten, mizukusasuisou.com.
  • Implementing Regulation (EU) 2016/1141, consolidated version of 7 August 2025, eur-lex.europa.eu.
  • Implementing Regulation (EU) 2025/1422 of 17 July 2025 (Misgurnus, Cipangopaludina chinensis, Marisa cornuarietis, Faxonius immunis, Cherax destructor), eur-lex.europa.eu.
  • Regulation (EU) No 1143/2014, Article 31 (pet animals held before listing), eur-lex.europa.eu.
  • French order of 14 February 2018 on the prevention of the introduction and spread of invasive alien animal species in mainland France, Annexes II-1 to II-5, legifrance.gouv.fr.
  • Implementing Regulation (EU) 2024/2013 (measures against the genus Pomacea), eur-lex.europa.eu; Decision 2012/697/EU.
  • French order of 8 December 1988 setting the list of protected fish species, DREAL Occitanie.
  • French order of 23 April 2007 setting the lists of protected molluscs, legifrance.gouv.fr.
  • French order of 8 January 2021 (protected amphibians and reptiles), legifrance.gouv.fr.
  • Fishipedia, Tanichthys albonubes page: size, 2 to 22 °C, diet, fishipedia.fr.
  • Höckelmann C., Pusch M., “The respiration and filter-feeding rates of the snail Viviparus viviparus”, Archiv für Hydrobiologie 149, 2000, schweizerbart.de.
  • medaka.fr: algae (nerites, Amano, Otocinclus), fry indoors (bladder snails, Neocaridina).