Dead medaka: the common causes and how to avoid a repeat

A dead medaka in a garden tub has rarely been killed by a disease. In the great majority of cases, it is the water: a new tank not yet cycled, a heatwave, a water change that was too abrupt, too much food. Next come transport, predators, and simply age, because a medaka lives two to three years. Finding the cause serves one purpose: not doing it again.

The common causes, from the most to the least likely

The order below matches what is met most often with a beginner.

1. The new tank, not yet cycled

This is the number one cause, and the least visible. A freshly filled tank does not yet have the bacteria that turn the ammonia from droppings into nitrites and then nitrates. Tokyo Aqua Garden counts about four weeks for this cycle to establish itself. In the meantime, ammonia and then nitrites rise, and the fish die one by one, with no visible lesion. The chocolate-brown gills described in the source on gills are the signature of nitrite poisoning. How to avoid a repeat: cycle the tank before putting fish in it, introduce only a few at a time, test the water in the first weeks, and follow the set-up guide.

2. Heat

The medaka tolerates 5 to 30 °C. Above 30 °C it is stressed; 34 °C is dangerous according to our fact base. Tokyo Aqua Garden places weakening above 35 °C and danger beyond 40 °C, but the ceiling of 30 °C remains the rule. Warm water holds less oxygen. The fish come up to breathe at the surface, then die during the night, when the plants consume oxygen in their turn. A black tub in full sun, or a 20 L planter on a terrace in the south, can get there in a single afternoon. How to avoid a repeat: shade half the tank, keep a substantial volume, add cooler water in small amounts, aerate gently. The details are in medaka through the seasons.

3. The abrupt water change

Changing all the water, or pouring in tap water straight from the tap, cold and chlorinated, kills within hours. The fish copes badly with a sudden temperature difference, and chlorine burns its gills. How to avoid a repeat: a third to a half of the volume at most, water left to stand for twenty-four hours or conditioned, poured in slowly, at the temperature of the tank, following the guide to water changes. A conditioner such as Medaka Care neutralises the chlorine in tap water.

4. Overfeeding

The medaka eats little at a time. What it does not take within two to three minutes falls to the bottom and rots. Tokyo Aqua Garden cites two consequences: indigestion, and the degradation of the water by leftovers. How to avoid a repeat: the ration is what disappears in two to three minutes, once or twice a day, and nothing below 10 °C. The feeding guide gives the quantities.

5. Transport and acclimatisation

A fish that dies within three days of arriving has most often suffered a shock: a difference in temperature or pH between the bag and the tank, or exhaustion from a long journey. How to avoid a repeat: float the closed bag for thirty minutes to an hour to equalise the temperature, then add tank water to the bag in three or four stages over thirty minutes to an hour, and finally net the fish across without pouring in the water from the bag, as Tokyo Aqua Garden describes. Do not feed on the first day. Ideally, quarantine for one to two weeks.

6. Diseases

They come in sixth place, not because they are rare, but because they almost always follow one of the causes above. Tokyo Aqua Garden cites fin rot, dropsy and white spot, usually introduced by a new fish or plant. A dead fish with a visible lesion, a white film, eaten fins or a pine-cone belly, points towards medaka diseases. How to avoid a repeat: quarantine newcomers, watch at feeding time, isolate the first sick fish.

7. Predators

A fish that has vanished is not a fish that died in the tank. In a garden tub in Europe, the dragonfly larva is the first predator, followed by the heron, the kingfisher, the cat and the crow. Wounds on several fish and disappearances without a body are their signature. The details are in predators of medaka.

8. Old age

A medaka lives two to three years, up to four in calm conditions. A fish bought as an adult at 3 cm is already several months old. A two-year-old that gets thin, curves and dies one morning with no other sign has simply reached the end. This case is described below.

The fish on the bottom or at the surface: what it tells you

A dead medaka generally sinks, then floats up after a day or two when the gases of decomposition swell it. Its position therefore says little about the cause. Tokyo Aqua Garden deals rather with the living fish that stays on the bottom, and distinguishes three situations.

  • Cold water. Below 15 °C activity drops, and around 10 °C the fish overwinters. Still on the bottom, it is not dying. Leave it alone until spring. See overwintering.
  • A predator present. Fish that hide on the bottom all the time, in the middle of the season, often have a dragonfly larva in the tank.
  • Disease or injury. A single fish on the bottom in summer while the others swim is ill. Isolation and a salt bath, described in the salt bath step by step.

A fish dead at the surface in summer, with the others gulping air, points to a lack of oxygen. A fish dead on the bottom, in a tank less than a month old, points to ammonia or nitrites.

The signs you could have seen

Deaths without warning are rare. In the preceding days, the fish ate more slowly, stayed apart, turned pale, breathed at the surface, or rubbed itself. These signs are described in recognising a sick medaka. The only way to see them is to watch the fish every day at feeding time, and to count.

Normal ageing

Tokyo Aqua Garden gives one to two years in the wild and three to five in captivity with good care, and places the start of the signs of old age at around two years. These signs are not a disease.

  • Slow thinning, especially of the belly, over weeks. Rapid thinning would be a disease.
  • The back curving, in an arc or an angle, because the bones and muscles weaken. This is the best-known sign.
  • Weakness against the current. The fish stays near the bottom or in the plants.
  • A loss of brilliance in the colours, limp fins.
  • Eyes that look larger, because the head is getting thinner. Not to be confused with exophthalmia, which appears within a few days.
  • The end of breeding: females no longer carry eggs, males no longer chase.
  • A slow reaction to food, granules spat out.

For these fish, the Japanese source gives three pieces of advice: reduce the current; give a powdered food or crushed granules; lower the water level so that rising to the surface costs less. An old medaka that ends its days in a small, calm tank, sheltered from the young, is a normal end to keeping fish.

What to do with the body

Remove the dead fish as soon as you see it, because it pollutes the water and the others eat it. Look at it: white film, raised scales, eaten fins, hollow or swollen belly. This one-minute examination often gives the cause.

Then there are two options. Bury it in the garden, at least 15 cm deep according to the Japanese source, away from a water point. Or put it in the household bin in a sealed bag. Never in the toilet or in a watercourse: a sick fish can carry germs that have no business in a stream. In the case of serial deaths, keep one body cool in a little tank water for a vet.

How to avoid a repeat

Cycle the tank for four weeks before the fish. At least one litre per fish, 30 L or more outdoors. Partial water changes, never total, never cold, never chlorinated. Shade in summer and a thermometer in the water. A ration eaten in two to three minutes, nothing below 10 °C. Quarantine for newcomers. A raised net against dragonflies and birds. And watch, count, every day at feeding time.

The key figures

Lifespan 2 to 3 years, up to 4 in calm conditions; signs of old age around 2 years (TAG)
Cycling a new tank about 4 weeks (TAG)
Temperature tolerance 5 to 30 °C; stress above 30 °C; danger at 34 °C
Activity reduced below 15 °C; overwintering around 10 °C (TAG)
Density 1 L per fish minimum
Ration eaten in 2 to 3 minutes; nothing below 10 °C
Quarantine 1 to 2 weeks (TAG)
Burying a fish at least 15 cm deep (TAG)

Frequently asked questions

My medaka have been dying one by one for a week, with no visible sign. Why?

If the tank is less than two months old, it is almost always the ammonia or nitrites of an uncycled tank. Test, do partial water changes every two or three days, and stop feeding for a few days.

My medaka died the day after I bought it. Is it the seller’s fault?

Most often it is the acclimatisation or a tank that was not ready. A fish sold in good health dies of a sudden temperature difference between the bag and the tank, or in an uncycled tank.

Can a medaka die of cold in winter in Europe?

A healthy adult in a tank of 30 L or more, with a deeper area, spends the winter outdoors. What kills is a tank that freezes to the bottom, or feeding below 10 °C. See the FAQ.

Sources